2025 Rankings

10 Best Dentists in Shelbyville, IN

Ranked from 20 verified dentists using our transparent Bayesian scoring system

20 Dentists Analyzed
4.8 Avg Rating
Updated 12/28/2025

How We Rank Dentists

Our ranking uses Bayesian averaging to balance star ratings with review volume. This prevents a dentist with one 5-star review from outranking an established practice with hundreds of 4.8-star reviews. The formula weighs both rating quality and the statistical confidence from having more reviews.

Top 10 Ranked Dentists

Ad

#1
Hallmark Orthodontics Shelbyville
Hallmark Orthodontics Shelbyville
5.0(197 reviews)
30 W Rampart Rd Ste 240, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Accepting Patients
Score: 4.98
#2
Randall L. Miller DDS
Randall L. Miller DDS
4.9(376 reviews)
117 West Washington St, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
Accepting Patients
Emergency Services
Score: 4.90
#3
Blue River Dental Care
Blue River Dental Care
4.9(359 reviews)
1818 N Riley Hwy ste a, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
Accepting Patients
Emergency Services
Score: 4.90
#4
Emhardt Pediatric Dentistry
Emhardt Pediatric Dentistry
4.9(200 reviews)
1818 N Riley Hwy suite b, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Accepting Patients
Score: 4.89
#5
Caring Family Dentistry Inc/ Robert J Caird DDS
Caring Family Dentistry Inc/ Robert J Caird DDS
4.9(184 reviews)
125 W Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
Accepting Patients
Score: 4.89
#6
Philip Batton
Philip Batton
5.0(6 reviews)
11 Howard St, Shelbyville, IN 461762616
Accepting Patients
Score: 4.85
#7
Dr. Betsy Crandall, DDS
5.0(3 reviews)
1818 N Riley Hwy ste a, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
Accepting Patients
Score: 4.83
#8
Jester Michael a DDS
Jester Michael a DDS
5.0(2 reviews)
16 Public Sq # C, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Accepting Patients
Score: 4.82
#9
Harrison Dental
Harrison Dental
4.8(45 reviews)
225 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
Accepting Patients
Emergency Services
Score: 4.80
#10
Clark Orthodontics
Clark Orthodontics
4.8(67 reviews)
1530 S Miller St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Accepting Patients
Emergency Services
Score: 4.80

Advertisement

Shelbyville Dental Stats

Total Dentists20
Average Rating
4.8
Avg Reviews/Dentist144

Advertisement

Advertisement

Frequently Asked Questions

How are the best dentists in Shelbyville, IN ranked?

Our ranking uses a Bayesian scoring system that balances star ratings with review volume. This mathematical approach prevents practices with very few reviews from unfairly outranking established dentists with hundreds of verified patient reviews. We analyze data from 20 dentists in Shelbyville to create these rankings.

How many dentists are in Shelbyville, IN?

There are 20 verified dental practices in Shelbyville, IN in our directory. Our data is continuously updated to ensure accuracy.

What should I look for when choosing a dentist in Shelbyville?

When choosing a dentist, consider factors like patient reviews, years of experience, services offered, insurance acceptance, and location convenience. Our ranking helps identify practices with consistently positive patient experiences based on verified review data.

How often is this ranking updated?

Our rankings are recalculated daily to reflect the latest patient reviews and rating changes. The current data was last updated on December 28, 2025.